Trying to decide which are the best Mötley Crüe albums is not an easy job.
Over the course of their career, Mötley Crüe went from a hungry young band tearing up the Los Angeles club scene to one of the biggest names in glam metal and hard rock. Along the way, they released nine studio albums that range from raw early metal to polished arena rock, experimental alternative metal, and a late-career return to their classic sound.
So, which record is the best Mötley Crüe album? Here are the Mötley Crüe albums ranked!
We’ve ranked all nine of the band’s studio albums from worst to best. And yes, there are some controversial choices here.
Mötley Crüe Albums Ranked
Embed from Getty ImagesBefore we get into the details, here’s our ranking of every Mötley Crüe studio album:
- Dr. Feelgood (1989)
- Shout at the Devil (1983)
- Too Fast for Love (1981)
- Mötley Crüe (1994)
- Girls, Girls, Girls (1987)
- Saints of Los Angeles (2008)
- Theatre of Pain (1985)
- New Tattoo (2000)
- Generation Swine (1997)
Mötley Crüe’s official discography lists these nine studio albums, beginning with Too Fast for Love in 1981 and ending with Saints of Los Angeles in 2008.
Now let’s get into the rankings.
9. Generation Swine (1997)
Let’s start with the controversial one.
Generation Swine is probably the easiest Mötley Crüe album to put at the bottom of the list, but that doesn’t mean it’s without interesting moments.
Released in 1997, the album arrived during a dramatically different musical climate. Grunge and alternative rock had changed the commercial landscape, and Mötley Crüe responded by experimenting with a darker, stranger sound.
The album also marked Vince Neil’s return to the band after John Corabi’s time as lead vocalist.
There are some genuinely interesting ideas here. “Afraid” has plenty of attitude, and the title track has an intentionally chaotic quality. But as an album, Generation Swine feels less focused than the records that established Mötley Crüe’s legacy.
It’s not necessarily a terrible record.
It’s just a strange place to start if you’re discovering Mötley Crüe.
Best tracks: “Afraid,” “Generation Swine,” “Beauty”
Released: 1997
8. New Tattoo (2000)
If Generation Swine is the weird Mötley Crüe album, New Tattoo is the understated one.
Released in 2000, New Tattoo attempted to reconnect with the band’s classic hard-rock identity. The album featured Randy Castillo on drums, with Tommy Lee absent while he pursued other projects.
That alone makes the album historically interesting.
Unfortunately, New Tattoo never quite reaches the heights of the band’s classic records. It has solid songs and plenty of familiar Crüe attitude, but it doesn’t have the same sense of danger or excitement that made the band’s 1980s albums so memorable.
Still, calling it the second-worst Mötley Crüe album doesn’t mean it’s unlistenable.
For dedicated fans, New Tattoo is worth revisiting precisely because it represents a transitional period in the band’s history.
Best tracks: “Hell on High Heels,” “New Tattoo,” “Treat Me Like the Dog I Am”
Released: 2000
7. Theatre of Pain (1985)
Now we’re getting into the difficult decisions.
Theatre of Pain contains one of the biggest songs Mötley Crüe ever recorded: “Home Sweet Home.”
It also contains their hugely successful cover of “Smokin’ in the Boys Room.”
So why is it only number seven?
Because the album has to be judged as an entire record rather than simply by its biggest singles.
Theatre of Pain arrived after Shout at the Devil and represented a shift toward a more accessible sound. The band was becoming increasingly successful, and their music was reaching a much larger audience.
There are plenty of good songs here, but the album doesn’t have the same consistency as Shout at the Devil or Dr. Feelgood.
Still, “Home Sweet Home” alone makes Theatre of Pain essential listening.
And let’s be honest: that piano intro is legendary.
Best tracks: “Home Sweet Home,” “Smokin’ in the Boys Room,” “Use It or Lose It”
Released: 1985
6. Saints of Los Angeles (2008)
Here’s where things get interesting.
Nearly three decades after their debut, Mötley Crüe returned with Saints of Los Angeles, their ninth and most recent studio album. The official Mötley Crüe discography lists its release date as June 24, 2008.
And honestly?
It’s better than it gets credit for.
The album arrived after years of lineup changes, side projects, personal drama, and musical experimentation. Rather than pretending the band was still 22 years old, Saints of Los Angeles leaned into the mythology and history that made Mötley Crüe famous.
The title track is an obvious highlight, but the album works best when it sounds like four musicians embracing what people actually wanted from Mötley Crüe: loud guitars, huge drums, sleaze, attitude, and anthemic choruses.
It isn’t their best album.
But it’s a surprisingly strong late-career statement.
Best tracks: “Saints of Los Angeles,” “Motherfucker of the Year,” “Down at the Whisky”
Released: 2008
5. Girls, Girls, Girls (1987)
If you want to hear the absolute definition of 1980s Mötley Crüe, put on Girls, Girls, Girls.
The album is dripping with Sunset Strip attitude.
Released in 1987, Girls, Girls, Girls captures the band’s larger-than-life image at almost its peak. It’s dirty, loud, cocky, and unapologetically excessive.
The title track became one of the band’s signature songs, while “Wild Side” remains one of their most beloved tracks.
The album isn’t as musically polished as Dr. Feelgood, and it doesn’t have the focused aggression of Shout at the Devil. But that’s almost beside the point.
Girls, Girls, Girls is a snapshot of Mötley Crüe at their most quintessentially Mötley Crüe.
It’s the leather pants, motorcycles, hairspray, whiskey, neon lights, and Sunset Strip record.
And sometimes that’s exactly what you want.
Best tracks: “Wild Side,” “Girls, Girls, Girls,” “You’re All I Need”
Released: 1987
4. Mötley Crüe (1994)
Now we’re getting controversial.
Mötley Crüe, the band’s 1994 self-titled album, is one of the most fascinating records in their entire catalog.
And it is criminally underrated.
This was the only Mötley Crüe studio album to feature John Corabi as lead vocalist. Instead of trying to recreate the band’s previous formula, the group went considerably heavier and darker.
The result is arguably one of the most musically ambitious albums Mötley Crüe ever made.
Songs like “Hooligan’s Holiday,” “Misunderstood,” and “Smoke the Sky” show a band willing to experiment with heavier songwriting and a different vocal approach.
Was it the Mötley Crüe that longtime fans expected?
No.
Was that necessarily a bad thing?
Absolutely not.
Commercially, the album couldn’t compete with the band’s 1980s output. But judging an album strictly by sales would be a mistake.
If you’re willing to step outside the Vince Neil era, the 1994 Mötley Crüe album deserves serious attention.
Best tracks: “Hooligan’s Holiday,” “Misunderstood,” “Smoke the Sky”
Released: 1994
3. Too Fast for Love (1981)
Before the arena tours. Before the massive record deals and MTV videos.
There was Too Fast for Love.
Mötley Crüe’s debut album is raw, dirty, energetic, and overflowing with the attitude that would eventually make them one of the biggest bands in rock.
It doesn’t have the polished production of Dr. Feelgood. It doesn’t need it.
There’s something special about hearing a band that hasn’t yet figured out exactly how successful it’s going to become.
“Live Wire,” “Too Fast for Love,” and “On With the Show” capture the early Crüe sound perfectly.
It’s the sound of a band trying to get noticed.
And they certainly succeeded.
Too Fast for Love was released in November 1981, making it the beginning of the studio-album story that would eventually produce nine records.
Best tracks: “Live Wire,” “Too Fast for Love,” “On With the Show”
Released: 1981
2. Shout at the Devil (1983)
Here’s where the argument gets serious.
Shout at the Devil is one of the greatest glam-metal albums of the 1980s.
Released in 1983, it helped establish Mötley Crüe as one of the defining young metal bands of the era. The album delivered an incredible combination of heavy riffs, attitude, melody, and theatricality.
And the songs?
Come on.
“Shout at the Devil.”
“Looks That Kill.”
“Too Young to Fall in Love.”
“Bastard.”
This is Mötley Crüe firing on all cylinders.
The album is also remarkably cohesive. Rather than simply being a collection of singles, Shout at the Devil feels like a complete statement.
Fan rankings consistently place it near the top of the Mötley Crüe catalog, and music-focused rankings also place it immediately behind Dr. Feelgood.
So why isn’t it number one?
Because there’s one album that edges it out.
Released: 1983
1. Dr. Feelgood (1989)
Yep.
Dr. Feelgood is one of the best Mötley Crüe albums ranked.
Fight me. 😂
Released in 1989, Dr. Feelgood represents the moment when everything came together for the band.
The songwriting was strong.
The performances were huge.
The production was enormous.
And the songs were some of the best Mötley Crüe ever recorded.
The album was produced by Bob Rock, and it became the band’s only album to reach number one on the Billboard 200. It remains widely regarded as the band’s strongest studio album, and music-ranking sites continue to place it at the top of their Mötley Crüe album lists.
Then there’s the track list.
“Dr. Feelgood.”
“Kickstart My Heart.”
“Without You.”
“Don’t Go Away Mad (Just Go Away).”
“Same Ol’ Situation (S.O.S.).”
That’s an absurd collection of songs.
What makes Dr. Feelgood particularly impressive is that the band achieved this level of success during a period when they were attempting to get sober and take greater control of their lives and careers.
Instead of losing their edge, they made their most focused and commercially successful album.
That’s why it gets the number one spot on Mötley Crüe albums ranked.
Released: 1989
The Complete Mötley Crüe Albums Ranked
Here’s the final ranking one more time:
| Rank | Album | Year |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Dr. Feelgood | 1989 |
| 2 | Shout at the Devil | 1983 |
| 3 | Too Fast for Love | 1981 |
| 4 | Mötley Crüe | 1994 |
| 5 | Girls, Girls, Girls | 1987 |
| 6 | Saints of Los Angeles | 2008 |
| 7 | Theatre of Pain | 1985 |
| 8 | New Tattoo | 2000 |
| 9 | Generation Swine | 1997 |
Mötley Crüe’s official discography confirms the nine studio albums and their release chronology.
Mötley Crüe Albums in Order
If you want to listen through the Mötley Crüe discography chronologically, here’s the order:
- Too Fast for Love — 1981
- Shout at the Devil — 1983
- Theatre of Pain — 1985
- Girls, Girls, Girls — 1987
- Dr. Feelgood — 1989
- Mötley Crüe — 1994
- Generation Swine — 1997
- New Tattoo — 2000
- Saints of Los Angeles — 2008
The band has also released compilations, soundtracks, EPs, and other material, but this list focuses specifically on the nine studio albums.
Interestingly, Mötley Crüe’s current official site is also celebrating the band’s classic 1981–1989 run with the Crücial Crüe 1981–1989 box set, which collects their first five studio albums: Too Fast for Love, Shout at the Devil, Theatre of Pain, Girls Girls Girls, and Dr. Feelgood.
What Is the Best Mötley Crüe Album?
If we’re talking about the best Mötley Crüe albums ranked from beginning to end, Dr. Feelgood gets the crown.
It has the production, songwriting, performances, singles, deep cuts, and consistency to justify the number-one spot.
But if you’re looking for the album that best represents the band’s raw 1980s identity, Shout at the Devil has a very legitimate argument.
And if you want the album that captures the hungry young band before superstardom, Too Fast for Love is impossible to ignore.
That’s what makes ranking Mötley Crüe albums so much fun.
There isn’t just one version of Mötley Crüe.
There’s the hungry club band.
The heavy-metal band.
The Sunset Strip party monsters.
The arena-rock superstars.
The experimental 1990s band.
And the veteran rockers looking back at their own mythology.
Every album represents a different chapter.
Which Mötley Crüe Album Should You Listen to First?
If you’re a new fan, start with Dr. Feelgood.
It’s the easiest introduction to everything that made Mötley Crüe famous.
Then go backward to Shout at the Devil and Too Fast for Love to hear how the band developed.
After that, check out Girls, Girls, Girls and Theatre of Pain for the band’s more accessible 1980s material.
And don’t skip the 1994 self-titled album.
Even though it’s a major departure, Mötley Crüe is one of the most interesting records in the band’s catalog.
The Verdict
Ranking Mötley Crüe albums is almost guaranteed to start an argument.
Some fans will put Shout at the Devil at number one. Others will choose Dr. Feelgood. Some will argue that Too Fast for Love is the band’s purest record. And there will always be someone ready to defend the John Corabi era.
That’s part of what makes Mötley Crüe so much fun.
Their catalog isn’t perfect.
It doesn’t need to be.
It’s loud, excessive, messy, occasionally brilliant, sometimes bizarre, and completely unapologetic.
And after more than four decades, people are still arguing about which Mötley Crüe album is the best.
That’s one hell of a legacy.
Facebook Comments